I’m a registered, card-carrying, certified Kerry-phobe and my instant reaction is that he performed some sort of miracle… an excellent performance, far better than any expectation I certainly had.
I evaluate this, of course, primarily as a TV show because that’s what it is. I’m not talking about any deep politics, because that’s what it isn’t. But it was a helluva show.
George W. Bush is commonly under-estimated. Now, we see how John Kerry has maintained a two decade career in politics. He’s no amateur either.
I think he took the screen from the first line, I’m John Kerry and I’m reporting for duty. An absolutely brilliant manuever. I thought he looked great running up the stairs. The use of the Bruce Springsteen sound bed perfectly clicked.
Some sort of new firmware was clearly dowloaded into the chip on the back of his neck and Kerry literally sprang to life. I’ve witnessed at least 20 speeches up close from this guy, but have never seem him cranked up to this level (not exactly hyper, but at least at the upper range of say Harrison Ford). He was probably helped out by the pressure to hurry through the speech to make sure it ended before the networks might pull the plug at 11pm Eastern.
Teresa tearing up, apparently genuinely, when Kerry expressed his love for her was also a great TV moment. A WHOLE lot better than the insulting charade imposed upon us by the old Bill and Hilary team.
The whole military, band of brothers, cordite and cojones theme in the set-up, would not have been my first choice. But I also think it worked great. With all those beefy swift boat vets up there it certainly didn’t look like some Code Pink event, did it?
Leaving aside the wisdom of the strategy, if the Democratic goal was to pull out the national security rug from under George Bush, then it can be said: Mission Accomplished. There was a clear single-mindedness at work here, percolating for months, going back to Kerry’s vow during the primaries to “Bring It On” and the promse was fulfilled. At least for tonight.
I was genuinely moved by Jim Rassman, the chubby guy who introduced Max Cleland, and who had his life saved by Kerry. It was a bravado appearance by a humble guy who until January was an anonymous retired Orange County sheriff. He came out of the woodwork during the Iowa primary and though a Republican, he showed up in Des Moines to endorse the campaign. I had the privilege of standing about 10 feet from both men in a community center when they had their first reunion since Vietnam and I found it deeply affecting. So there’s my bias.
Max Cleland, of course, is a tough act to top and he was rolled out, literally, for maximum effectiveness.
Now the negatives. Or better said, the parts I disliked.
On substance: While there were SOME good pushbacks at Bush on several subjects, including the war, and while I liked very much that Kerry said he deals in “complexities,” he certainly offered no nuance, no detail and no satisfactory explanation of what he would do in Iraq. Or what’s wrong with the current course. I personally do NOT support an immediate withdrawal of troops and I wouldn’t want or expect Kerry to make that call. But he should have clearly said the war was bollixed up, that its $300 billion price tag is unacceptable, that it is creating a backlash that will haunt us for decades to come and that he was going to at least … shift… if not change course. More on that in the days to come.
As to the rest of the policy stuff… no surprises. Pure Clintonism. And anyone who would expect anything else is living on some other planet. That’s what Kerry is. And that’s what the Democrats are. Period. Full Stop.
Negatives on the TV Show aspect: “Getting to know John Kerry” doesn’t mean having a pajama party with his whole flippin’ family. I found Teresa’s “boys” and John’s “girls” beyond annoying. Maybe it’s the knowledge that the family is worth a billion dollars that makes me suspect they are spoiled brats. (Note to Alexandra Kerry: You’re 30 years old, you’re Dad is likely to be President. Your step-mom is fabulously wealthy. It’s about time you got a real profession other than wannabe movie director).
I know some found the childhood stories about trying to save hamsters endearing. I found it downright frightening that this sort of crap has anything to do with the process of selecting the president of the most powerful country on earth. But then again, all really good TV shows, seen as effective mass spectacle, have a frightening aspect to them.
Now, we’ll see what kind of bounce any of this gets in the polls. In the meantime, I will be bouncing back home to Los Angeles Friday morning. I’ll take one day off. And then on Sunday I’m planning to head out to Arizona and New Mexico for a week to do some reporting to see if the great DNC 2004 Show has moved any significant number of swing voters into the Democratic column.
A final word on convention week. It’s been a lot of fun, as usual, covering this event for the last week. And blogging it has been a special treat. The software we use allows us to monitor the web traffic that is generated and I can see that a good number of you have been logging on and reading these rants. Thank you.
But you have been unusually quiet, perhaps guessing that the intensity of this event would permit me little time to respond to comments. True. But now that it’s over, let me hear from you. Post your comments below reacting to the convention, Kerry and the coverage.
See you back in L.A.
P.S. Conservative columnist Robert George -- a former Gingrich staffer-- says he thinks he might have just heard the acceptance speech of the "next president."
Pat Buchanan just said he thought the speech was remarkable, that it resonated with him.
Joe Trippi, former Howard Dean campaign manager, says that the Kerry we saw tonight is the fearsome Kerry that whupped Dean in Iowa.
Pretty good reviews.